Full Vinegar Collection

This is everything we make: barrel-aged wine vinegars, raw apple cider vinegars with the mother, malt vinegars fermented from real beer, junmai rice vinegar, sherry, honey and the gift sets built from them. If you are buying craft vinegar online for the first time, start here and narrow down.

Start with what you cook

What makes these different from supermarket vinegar

Industrial vinegar is made in a stainless tank in under a day. Ours is fermented slowly and aged in oak barrels at a historic mill in Worcester, Massachusetts, using the 1823 drip method. That time is the whole product: it turns raw acid into something with fruit and structure behind it, which is why our vinegar seasons a dish rather than just souring it. Everything is small batch, most of it is raw and unfiltered, and none of it is diluted acetic acid with coloring. The comparison is spelled out in industrial vs craft vinegar and why small-batch vinegar tastes better.

If you are not sure yet

Buy a sampler rather than guessing. The mini bottle sampler sets put five styles in front of you in one order, and the full-size bottle you eventually buy will be the right one. If you are buying for someone else, gifts and gear has the boxed sets.

Common questions

  • Which vinegar should I own if I only own one? Red wine vinegar for savory cooking, chardonnay white wine vinegar if you mostly make salads.
  • Do these need refrigerating? No. Vinegar is self-preserving. Keep bottles capped and out of direct sunlight.
  • What is the sediment? In the raw cider vinegars it is the mother, and it is a sign the vinegar was never filtered flat or pasteurized. See apple cider vinegar with the mother.
  • Are any gluten free? The rice and wine vinegars are. The malt vinegars are fermented from barley and are not.

 

Free shipping on orders over $85 within the contiguous US. New to this? Start here.

Vinegar FAQs

How is vinegar made?

Traditional vinegar is made by fermenting some type of alcohol—think beer, wine, cider, sake – into acetic acid. To make vinegar you need five key ingredients: alcohol, vinegar bacteria, oxygen, heat, and time.

Depending on the ABV (alcohol by volume) of the specific alcohol you may need to add water to dilute the alcohol. This is because when you get to a certain height in ABV the vinegar bacteria simply cannot operate and eat away at the alcohol to transform it into acetic acid or vinegar. This, by the way, is why your bottle of scotch will never turn into vinegar.

Over time and at the right temperature the vinegar bacteria will eat away at the wine or cider and turn into vinegar. Depending on the level of ABV, the environmental conditions, and the amount of vinegar you are trying to make this can take anywhere from two weeks to about six months simply to complete the fermentation. During this time you will see that a film, often thick, will form on top of the liquid. This is vinegar mother and is a byproduct of vinegar fermentation.

Better traditional vinegars are then aged for months to years after fermentation. This allows the vinegars to develop more nuanced flavor profiles and not just be acid bombs.

Reach out if you have any other questions on how vinegar is made.

Which ingredients do you use to make your vinegar?

The main ingredient in vinegar is alcohol.

To make our vinegars the only alcohols we use are select American wines, beers, cider, and sakes.

Our vinegars stand on the shoulders of America’s microbrewers and vintners and we are thankful for their efforts and craft.

What is co-fermentation and why is it better than infusing?

Some of our vinegar are “co-fermented” or “fermented flavors”.

This means that while our alcohol (e.g. wine or cider) ferments into vinegar we introduce different fruits and spices into the liquid mixture. As the bacteria eat away at the alcohol they also interact with the fruit or spices and this ultimately produces very unique vinegars with a greater depth of flavor.

Co-fermented vinegars contrast with infused vinegars. You make infused vinegar the way you would make tea. You start with a vinegar that has already fully fermented and then you put in spices or fruits to infuse vinegars with a specific taste. These flavors tend to be more aggressive and less nuanced than co-fermented flavors.

We never infuse our vinegars. And buyer beware that there are companies out there that say they make vinegar but all they are doing is buying vinegars and then infusing them. Vinegar makers are those that ferment alcohol into vinegar, not those using purchased vinegars as an ingredient. Well now we are all worked up…