Mystery Four Pack Gift Box
Four full-size surprises—gift-ready and seriously good
The Mystery Four Pack Gift Box is the easiest way to explore AVW for less. We pick the bottles, you pocket the savings, and everything arrives packed in our custom gift box with a recipe card inside. It’s pantry-refresh meets delight-to-open. $39 (regular $52).
What’s inside
Four standard 8.5 oz glass bottles—no minis, no duplicates—curated from our current small-batch lineup, hand-packed in our AVW gift box with a recipe card.
How it works
It’s a true mystery set. You can’t choose the exact varietals; we select a balanced mix for you based on what’s tasting great right now. Limited quantity—when it’s gone, it’s gone.
Why cooks love this box
Because you get real, slow-fermented vinegar with barrel depth—our early-1800s method, then time in oak, bottled raw and unfiltered—wrapped up as an easy gift. Dressings go silkier, marinades season without shouting, and pan sauces snap into focus.
Quick ways to use it tonight
House vinaigrette: 2 parts olive oil to 1 part any wine vinegar, plus salt.
Warm grain bowl: Fold a spoon of cider vinegar into farro or rice, then finish with olive oil.
Roast finisher: Splash a malty or sherry style over hot vegetables right off the sheet pan.
Quantity:
Free shipping on orders over $85 to the same address in the contiguous US.
Raves & Reviews
-
"THE MOST SURPRISING AND DELIGHTFUL VINEGARS I’VE EVER TRIED"
-
-
"VINEGARS WITH A SENSE OF PLACE"
-
Good to know
Price: $39 (regular $52).
Bottle size: 4 × 8.5 oz (full size).
No duplicates: We guarantee a mix of styles in every box.
Packaging: Custom AVW gift box + recipe card included.
Shipping: Free over $75 in the contiguous US; $7.99 flat rate otherwise.
Process: Slow-fermented with our revived 1823 approach, then barrel-aged and bottled raw and unfiltered.
The Mystery Gift Set is the best way to explore American Vinegar Works at a fraction of the price.
Whether you are looking to restock your own pantry with new flavors or grab a high-quality gift without breaking the bank, this set covers all the bases. We select the flavors, pack them in our custom gift box, and you get the savings.
What’s inside the box?
-
Full-Sized Flavor: You will receive four of our standard 8.5oz glass bottles (no sample sizes here!).
-
Curated Variety: We guarantee a mix of styles in every box—no duplicates.
-
Gift-Ready Presentation: The bottles arrive packed in our beautiful custom gift box with a recipe card included for inspiration.
How it works: This is a true mystery box! You cannot pick the specific varietals—we pick them for you based on our current small-batch selection. It is a fun roll of the dice on flavor with the quality you always expect from us.
Limited quantity available. While supplies last.
Mystery Four Pack Gift Box FAQs
Can I choose the bottles?
Are these minis or full size?
Will I get duplicates?
What’s the shipping policy?
How do you make your vinegars?
Worth Waiting For
Modern vinegars have lost their way, so we stepped back in time to recreate a process from 1823. Our equipment doesn’t exist anymore so we remade it in partnership with local universities.
After slow fermentation our vinegars are barrel aged before being hand bottled raw and unfiltered. It all takes a lot more time and care but we think the results are spectacular. I hope you will too.
Vinegars with a Sense of Place
We create vinegars with flavor profiles that reflect a sense of place by working exclusively with American wines, ciders, and brews.
Our vinegar works is housed in the blacksmith shop for an old textile mill complex in the heart of New England that is on the National Register of Historic Places.
