Olive Oil

California olive oil has one clear advantage over most imported supermarket bottles: you can tell how old it is. Olive oil is a fresh product that degrades from the moment it is pressed, and a lot of what sits on shelves has spent a long time in transit and storage.

Our California olive oil

Extra Virgin Olive Oil: California Organic is cold-pressed and certified organic. Grassy and peppery, with the bitterness at the back of the throat that tells you the polyphenols are still intact. That peppery catch is a feature, not a fault, and it fades as an oil ages.

Using oil and vinegar together

These are two halves of the same job. Oil carries flavor and softens acid; vinegar cuts fat and lifts everything around it. Three parts oil to one part vinegar is the standard vinaigrette, and our vinaigrette guide works through the variations. Beyond dressings: finish soup with a swirl, dress a tomato before salting it, or pour it over warm beans with a splash of sherry vinegar.

Buying it in a set

Common questions

  • How should I store it? Cool, dark, capped, away from the stove. Heat and light are what turn oil stale.
  • How long after opening? Use it within a few months. Unlike vinegar, olive oil does not improve with time.
  • Can I cook with it? Yes, for normal sauteing. For a good extra virgin oil the best use is still raw or added at the end, where you taste what you paid for.

 

See the pairings in olive oil and vinegar or the whole range in the full vinegar collection. Free shipping over $85 in the contiguous US.

Olive Oil FAQs

How do vinegar and olive oil complement each other?

We believe that olive oil and vinegar complement each other perfectly, creating a harmonious balance of flavors that elevate any dish. The rich, smooth texture of high-quality olive oil pairs beautifully with the sharp, tangy notes of our artisan vinegars, making them a dynamic duo in the culinary world. When combined, the acidity of the vinegar cuts through the richness of the olive oil, enhancing the flavors of both and creating a well-rounded taste experience. This synergy is particularly evident in salads, where a simple vinaigrette of olive oil and vinegar can transform fresh greens into a gourmet delight. Additionally, the combination is versatile, enhancing everything from marinades and dressings to dips and finishing touches.

By using our artisan vinegars alongside premium olive oil, we offer a delightful way to bring out the best in both ingredients, making every meal more enjoyable.

What are some creative ways to use olive oil?

We find that there are many creative ways to use olive oil, especially when paired with our vinegar.

One of our favorite methods is to create unique vinaigrettes and dressings by blending different vinegars with olive oil, herbs, and spices for salads that burst with flavor. We also enjoy using olive oil as a base for marinades, where it can help tenderize meats while the vinegar adds a tangy kick. Drizzling olive oil over roasted vegetables or fresh bread, accompanied by a splash of our vinegar, transforms simple dishes into gourmet experiences. Additionally, incorporating olive oil into baking, such as in cakes and breads, provides a rich, moist texture and enhances the flavors.

By combining olive oil with our artisan vinegars in these various ways, we can explore endless culinary possibilities that bring depth and excitement to our meals.

How is your olive oil and vinegar better than grocery store brands?

Our olive oil and vinegar stand out from grocery store brands due to our commitment to quality, craftsmanship, and the use of premium ingredients. Unlike mass-produced products, our artisan vinegars are made using traditional fermentation methods, often aged in wooden barrels to develop complex flavors that you won’t find in typical store-bought versions.

By focusing on small batches, we ensure that each bottle of our olive oil and vinegar maintains its distinct, high-quality profile. This attention to detail results in a superior taste experience, with more nuanced and robust flavors that elevate any dish. We take pride in offering products that are not just ingredients, but essential components of a refined and enjoyable culinary adventure.

Let customers speak for us

from 1673 reviews
So delicious!

We have used this on several dishes for a little flavor and I'm planning to do fried fish and fries this weekend with this as a highlight!

Dee P.

The greatest vinegar 😁

Sharon

an excellent white wine vinegar crisp clean acidity

MICHAEL M.

Lovely. Very high quality vinegar!

David
Birthday gift for my sister

My sister was thrilled with the gift set. I also added a couple of other vinegars that I love…and she did too! Such wonderful vinegar flavors that enhance everything we eat!!!

Carla H.

Great vinegar.

Gail G.
Superior Vinegar- will be repeat customer

I love vinegar and your regular cider vinegar, malted beer vinegar, cider vinegar w/ blueberry and cider vinegar w/ cranberry is awesome and will be a repeat customer for life.
I am 78 and a 14th generation New Englander with maternal and paternal roots back in Dedham, Massachusetts and Providence RI back to 1636. I am 78 now and born in Boston but due to job and marriage and kids have lived at the New Jersey Shore since 1978- age 30.

John Carter ANGELL
520 Hillside Ave
Pine Beach
New Jersey 08741
[****]
[****]

JOHN
I keep these in-stock in my kitchen

I keep these in-stock in my kitchen. They are reasonably shelf stable and I like the varitey.

Anonymous
Love your vinegar’s everything came fine right

Love your vinegar’s everything came fine right on time and I enjoy them very much

Customer L.E.
Great vinegar

The best vinegars I have ever tasted. The apple cider vinegar is real, not apple cider flavored vinegar like most. It is made with real apples, and you can taste the difference. Fantastic used making hot bacon dressing for wilted salads.
I highly recommend.

kevin h.
I’ve been using these vinegars for three years and I would use nothing else! The red wine vinegar

I’ve been using these vinegars for three years and I would use nothing else! The red wine vinegar is my go to. I am currently enjoying the Honey Wine Vinegar, Rice Wine Vinegar, Chardonnay Wine Vinegar. The quality is exceptional !

Nancy K.
Trust the Freebie

The free bonus bottle of hot vinegar is not something I would have ordered, but I love it—so good on garden-ripened tomatoes! Ordering was easy, delivery prompt, all contents in good condition. The vinegar has a depth and richness that grocery store vinegar just doesn’t have.

Martha G.T.
Superior quality, tasty and smooth

Did a taste test with your apple vinegar and the major national brand we use. First diluted in water then straight. In both concentrations your product wins hands down. Smoother and tastier. The choking, why'd-I-do-that response with the straight vinegar was almost worth it.

Anonymous
Good vinegar, and samplers are fun and practical

American Vinegar Works makes delicious vinegars. I don't like them all equally, but that's what makes the sampler packs great. I chose what I wanted to try. I highly recommend the miles from the tree cider vinegar! I also like that I can buy a small bottle when I only want a little of something specialized for a recipe. It makes a good reason to try some more kinds!

Harriet

Great vinegars

Alexa J.